Why I won’t be attending Limmud SA JHB 2012
I just received an e-mail update from Limmud SA, and promptly unsubscribed from the mailing list. The catalyst was their decision to hold it as a residential event for the 2nd year in a row, but there’s more…
Up to and including 2010, I had only ever missed Limmud JHB one year. Despite the dramatic increase in costs each successive year, it had become a fixture on the calendar for my daughter (Young Limmud age) and I. In fact, Limmud 2010 JHB was so spectacular that I decided to put my name down as a volunteer for 2011.
I registered and, towards the end of 2010, was invited to an initial get-together and motivational session for the 2011 volunteers, and again provided my details and stated where I thought I could contribute. After that, nothing. Absolutely nothing, until months later when I, along with everyone else on the mailing list, received notice of the 2011 event and the shock news that it would be a residential event.
Costs had increased steadily over the years, but the two of us were still able to attend the 2010 event for under R1,000. Attending the 2011 event, however, would require an investment of over R4,000 and an entire weekend away!
In addition, not only was Limmud now residential, but it would be held out of town at a Vaal resort. This made the residential part mandatory instead of an option. Whereas, had the event been held in town, one could have chosen to stay over (or not). (I understand that a bus day-trip option was later offered for the Sunday, but by that stage I’d lost interest and made other arrangements.)
I logged my objections on their Facebook Page and was given the assurance that, despite the cost, this was not intended to be an elitist or “exclusive” event (in the true sense of excluding people who cannot afford the ticket). Huh!? How is an event with that kind of price tag not elitist or exclusive, even discriminatory? As for volunteering, well I should contact them again and offer my services again…
What I found even more disturbing were the stories of “religious coercion” that emerged after the event. Because Limmud had bookend the entire venue for the weekend, the organisers felt able to dictate to delegates how they should observe the Sabbath, with TV being banned, for instance.
So, for the 2nd year, Limmud SA JHB will be a residential event. I still wish the organisers the best of luck. I just won’t be there.